Not worth going into details? Yep, one of the supps, where this is clearly the case was suggested by Colby who wants me to address sodium-R-lipoic acid, which is nothing else but R-ALA and in my mind a scientifically unsupported spin-off of ALA that may in fact be inferior to the regular racemic form of lipoic acid which contains both the R- as well as the purportedly pro-inflammatory S-form of ALA (more about the benefits of inflammation in the context of hormesis).
Before we start, just a brief reminder: Do not consider spending your money on any of these supplements before you've not made / begun to make the lifestyle changes described in episode one of this series. Otherwise all of these supplements are nothing but a crutch supporting you on your journey along the Royal Road to Diabesity.Ok, enough of the finger wagging for today; let's get to "your" supplement wishes. Let's see, what have we got?
- Lemon juice (citric acid) - This is another of Colby's suggestions (also asked for by "anonymous" who just missed his chance of becoming semi-famous). Colby says, he read about lemon juice in Tim Ferriss' Four Hour Body (a fascinating book, by the way; the only problem is that people forget that it's an N=1 experiment and few things that worked for Tim will work for you or anyone else, as effectively).
Not citric acid specific enough, but worth mentioning: In a study where citric acid (the purported active ingr. in lemon juice) was admin. w/ thiamine, arginine and caffeine it lead to FAT GAIN in normal weight individuals (Muroyama. 2003) - this should remind you of the smart rules of supplementation, right?
Using lemon juice for cooking purposes, on the other hand, has been shown to reduce the formation of pro-diabetic glycation end products during cooking.
Using a marinade with lemon juice for example will reduce the production of AGEs in beef by 10% (Uribarri. 2010)
Overall, lemon juice is thus another "C" as in "you C-an try it if you are looking for yet another C-rutch", but certainly nothing that is going to solve any of your problems.
- Resistant Starches - Starches that cannot be broken down in the small intestine and will thus not release any glucose are a no-brainer, as far as improvements in insulin sensitivity are concerned. Think of them as fat, because that is what the "really resistant" starches, i.e. those that make it almost unharmed to the long intesine (RS-3 for the natural ones and RS-4 for the artificial ones). Once they have arrived there they are metabolized to short chain fatty by the bacteria in your gut.
WMHDP pancakes are not good for you, but maybe better than regular ones.
It is thus the conversion to SCFA and not the resistant starches which come in the varieties RS1 (=physically inaccessible or digestible resistant starch, such as that found in seeds or legumes and unprocessed whole grains), RS2 (=resistant starch that occurs in its natural granular form, such as uncooked potato, green banana flour and high amylose corn), RS3 (=resistant starch that is formed when starch-containing foods are cooked and cooled such as in legumes, bread, cornflakes and cooked-and-chilled potatoes, pasta salad or sushi rice) and RS4 (= starches that have been chemically modified to resist digestion, e.g. WMHDP), due to which RS1-4 get a "B" as in "B-etter than regular starches or sugars, B-ut no quick fix for sure". They are useful only in conjunction with the previously mentioned life-style changes from episode I (no, I will never tire of repeating this ;-).
From an anti-diabetes perspecitve more coffee appears to help more; in view of its effects on the central nervous system you still better limit your intake to max. 3-4 cups per day (Matusheski. 2012)
In addition, I would like to invite you to take a look at the image to the right that shows quite clearly that the anti-diabesity effect, of which you have learned that it could mediated by the benefits of caffeine on the liver (cf. "Diabetes & the Liver - Chicken vs. Egg" | read more) are reversed when you are already obese, diabetic & hyperlipidemic.
While I refuse to officially rank coffee, I can tell you that most of the negative side effects are dose-dependently brought about by its caffeine content, and that I personally have a "never consume more than 500mg caffeine or 2-3 cups per day" rule in place and regret it deeply whenever I defy my rule for more than 2-3 days in a row - not on the diabetic side of things (I am rather a low blood glucose guy), but as far as overall well-being and energy levels are concerned.
SuppVersity suggested read: "Want to Relieve Insulin Resistance? Eat your Blueberries!" | read more
What I want to give you instead is a real world example: A 2010 study by Stull et al. who found that the provision of isocaloric smoothies with and without 22.5 g blueberry bioactives to 32 obese, nondiabetic, and insulin-resistant subjects for 6 weeks led to a significant improvement of insulin sensitivity in the absence of changes in adiposity.
According to the scientists the same effects could be achieved with 2 cups of fresh blueberries (or 45g of the powder they used to prepare the study) that makes blueberries an "A" as in "A must, but A bit expensive to have them every day". That does not change that consuming blueberries on a regular basis is going to help you improve or maintain you insulin sensitivity.
Thanks for reminding me of including such a reasonable whole food in the series, Erik - ah and Ian, if you want pterostilbene, just eat your blueberries.
MCT + Chili a fat loss duo that will reduce your insulin sensitivity. That does not matter while you are dieting or low-to-no-carbing, but is a no go when you are doing neither of that.Note: If you are wondering why I am so bold to state that MCTs reduce your insulin sensitivity (see caption of the image), here is the study (Marcal. 2013) and this is the explanation: Fast fats = increase in FFA in the blood = insulin resistance. At least in an "average" = non-low carb + non-calorically restricted scenario it's as easy as that. When you replace the "Atkins fats" (= long chain fatty acids) with MCTs, on the other hand, you will obviously see benefits from medium chain triglycerides (cf. De Vogel-van den Bosch. 2011).In other words, if it's not used to cut body fat (in conjunction with diet and exercise) it's unlikely that capsaicin will help with insulin sensitivity, which is why it gets a "D" as in "D-on't use". And that would be the case even if capsaicin did not have some dubious effects on the Langerhans cells in the pancreas Gram. 2007). It's weight loss effects are totally overblown (see today's Facebook news) and it has been shown to blunt the beneficial effects of the "satiety hormone" cholecystokinin two decades ago (Ritter. 1985). If you want a "hot" alternative, you should thus go for plain onions (Babu. 1997).
- Ginseng (purported active ingredient ginsenoside Rh2): While there are plenty of rodent studies available, Cho et al. were the first to investigate the effect of Korean red ginseng in human beings and the results of their study which has been published in March this year are not exactly impressive.
It's easy to see: Ginseng doesn't help healthy people. While the reduction in insulin sensitivity in response to 6g ginseng was not significant, it's obvious that healthy individuals won't benefit (Cho. 2013)
"Korean red ginseng had no significant effect on improving the insulin sensitivity over time." (Cho. 2013)This is significant, because you can safely assume that its effects on individuals with lower body fat percentages (like you?) are probably bordering zero.
Other studies report a physiologically irrelevant improvement in postprandial glycemia, when ginseng (in this case American) was administered exactly 40min before an oral glucose challenge (Vuskan. 2001). And the (non-significant) reduction in insulin sensitivity in the healthy but chubby subjects of the Cho study (see figure on the top right of this paragraph) is a perfect example of the previously cited imperative of applying the selectivity and specificity principles, when you select and buy your dietary supplements (learn more).
In view of the fact that there is some allegedly inconclusive and "not convincing" (Kim. 2011) scientific support for the usefulness of ginseng in sick people, it still qualify for a "C-" as in "C-ould be useful for those who are already suffering from what we call the "metabolic syndrome". Of these, especially those who suffer from high blood lipids (e.g. Mucalo. 2012) could benefit and in these individuals you will probably also observe downstream improvements in glucose metabolism. These are however secondary to the reduction in blood lipis and will not occur in people like yourself, people who work out regular and lead the lives of someone who has found his / her way to physical culture.
Suggested read: "Beyond Warding Off Holiday Weight Gain: 250-1000mg of Freeze-Dried Ginger Reduce Visceral Fat In Rodents on High Fat Diet" | read more
Ginger has also been shown to exhibit appetite suppressant effects (Mansou. 2012), to improve the thermic effect of food (ibid.), to hold potential as an anti-NAFLD (non-fatty liver disease) "drug" (Sahebkar. 2011), to ameliorate the negative side effects of diabetes (Li. 2012), and to improve glucose level, HbA1c and insulin sensitivity in type 2 diabetic patients (Mahluji. 2013)
For whole ginger (i.e. not ginger extracts) the dosages are usually in the 2-4g range. And while this is probably not going to hurt anyone, there is simply too little evidence that the beneficial effects of ginger are not "solely" mediated by its potent anti-inflammatory action to award an "A"-level recommendation with respect to its insulin sensitizing effects.
So, assuming that its usefulness is more or less limited to individuals with underlying inflammatory problems ginger gets a "B" as in "there are few B-etter general health foods out there, B-ut its benefits in lean individuals are probably not glucose specific". If you are looking for general anti-obesity effects, on the other hand, I'd suggest you go and grab a couple of ginger roots right now ;-)
- Mate tea (Ilex paraguariensis): The evidence from human studies for or against the usefulness of the last supplement on Erik's wishlist is not exactly what I would call extensive. A study by Klein et al. from 2011 is probably as good as it gets and, as it was to be expected, the results suggest that we are once more dealing with an anti-inflammatory agent that will have the greatest impact on people who already suffer from diabetes / the metabolic syndrome.
SuppVersity suggested Read: "The Leptin-Ilex!? Does Yerba Mate (Ilex Paraguariensis) Restore Leptin Sensitivity or Does it Just Help You Lose Body Fat by Curbing Your Appetite?" | read more, but don't forget that fat loss and glucose sensitivity are not one and the same. While The former usually entails the latter, it does not always work the other way around.
Just like many other purported "insulin sensitizers", Mate is thus another food / supplement that has only secondary effects on blood glucose. It's another "C" supplement with "C as in C-an be used by the obese diabetic". Drinking liters of mate, even if you don't like it, just to increase your glucose sensitivity does however seem to be pretty useless for anyone who ain't suffering from abnormal lipid levels and increased whole body inflammation.
- Gymnema Sylvestre - While there are a couple of human studies on gymnema their significance suffers from heavy sponsoring and / or the co-administration of other supplements. If you plod through the research that's out there you will however find some evidence for its usefulness in full-blown type II diabetics (500mg/day; Kumar. 2010) and some interesting effects on the sweet taste receptors (Sigoillot. 2012). The latter are blocked by gymnemic acid and could, at least when we are talking about the glucose receptors in the gut, modify both the absorption kinetics and hormonal response of / to glucose.
In the end, the said effects on the sweet taste receptors may also be involved in the effects Shanmugasundaram et al. describe in a 1990 paper. In their study, the administration of 400mg of an GS extract lead to significant improvements in glucose management in 27 patients with insulin-dependent (=severe) diabetes. Since we do not really know that, and in view of the occasional reports of adverse reactions to gymnema supplements (e.g. a case-report by Shiyovich et al. (2010) that links the consumption of gymnema supplements to toxic hepatitis), I will still rank it as "D" as in "D-o wait until there is more and better research available".
I personally consider the risk of consuming corresponding supplements very low, but the same goes for any potential benefits ... and one thing is certain, it's not "a potential panacea for the management of diabetes" which is what MJ Leach writes to attract attention to his 2007 review of the literature in the Journal of Alternative Complementary Medicine (Leach. 2007)
Suggested Read: "Purported Health Supplement Bitter Melon Induces Oxidative Damage in Rat Testes and Reduces Testosterone Levels by >50%" | read more
"Bitter melon may have hypoglycemic effects, but data are not sufficient to recommend its use in the absence of careful supervision and monitoring." (Basch. 2003)Did that change over the course of the past 10 years? Of course not.
So unless Google and sensationalist advertisements that are supposed to look like real journal articles are your main sources of "information" about dietary supplements you will probably have to concede that
"[...] clinical trial data with human subjects are limited and flawed by poor study design and low statistical power [and] the clinical data regarding the anti-diabetic potentials of M. charantia and calls for better-designed clinical trials to further elucidate its possible therapeutic effects" (Leung. 2009)and conclude that
"[t]here is insufficient evidence on the effects of momordica charantia for type 2 diabetes mellitus. Further studies are therefore required to address the issues of standardization and the quality control of preparations. For medical nutritional therapy, further observational trials evaluating the effects of momordica charantia are needed before RCTs are established to guide any recommendations in clinical practice." (Ooi. 2013)That does not necessarily mean that it does not work, at all, but as a direct comparison with metformin shows, it's not a real alternative for type II diabetics (Fuangchan. 2011), whose HbA1c levels declined by meager 0.24% after being treated with a bitter melon supplement three times a day for three months (undisclosed amount of active ingredients in the caps; cf. Dans. 2007). I hope I do not have to point out that it is unrealistic to expect that you would see better effects in non-diabetics.
I guess, it's probably not necessary to say that, but bitter melon is a bitter pill that gets a "D" as in "D-on't fall for the hype".
- Babu PS, Srinivasan K. Influence of dietary capsaicin and onion on the metabolic abnormalities associated with streptozotocin induced diabetes mellitus. Mol Cell Biochem. 1997 Oct;175(1-2):49-57.
- Fuangchan A, Sonthisombat P, Seubnukarn T, Chanouan R, Chotchaisuwat P, Sirigulsatien V, Ingkaninan K, Plianbangchang P, Haines ST. Hypoglycemic effect of bitter melon compared with metformin in newly diagnosed type 2 diabetes patients. J Ethnopharmacol. 2011 Mar 24;134(2):422-8.
- Islam MS, Choi H. Dietary red chilli (Capsicum frutescens L.) is insulinotropic rather than hypoglycemic in type 2 diabetes model of rats. Phytother Res. 2008 Aug;22(8):1025-9.
- Kim S, Shin BC, Lee MS, Lee H, Ernst E. Red ginseng for type 2 diabetes mellitus: a systematic review of randomized controlled trials. Chin J Integr Med. 2011 Dec;17(12):937-44.
- Kumar SN, Mani UV, Mani I. An open label study on the supplementation of Gymnema sylvestre in type 2 diabetics. J Diet Suppl. 2010 Sep;7(3):273-82.
- Leach MJ. Gymnema sylvestre for diabetes mellitus: a systematic review. J Altern Complement Med. 2007 Nov;13(9):977-83. Review.
- Leung L, Birtwhistle R, Kotecha J, Hannah S, Cuthbertson S. Anti-diabetic and hypoglycaemic effects of Momordica charantia (bitter melon): a mini review. Br J Nutr. 2009 Dec;102(12):1703-8. doi: 10.1017/S0007114509992054. Epub . Review.
- Li Y, Tran VH, Duke CC, Roufogalis BD. Preventive and Protective Properties of Zingiber officinale (Ginger) in Diabetes Mellitus, Diabetic Complications, and Associated Lipid and Other Metabolic Disorders: A Brief Review. Evid Based Complement Alternat Med. 2012;2012:516870.
- Mansour MS, Ni YM, Roberts AL, Kelleman M, Roychoudhury A, St-Onge MP. Ginger consumption enhances the thermic effect of food and promotes feelings of satiety without affecting metabolic and hormonal parameters in overweight men: a pilot study. Metabolism. 2012 Oct;61(10):1347-52.
- Marçal AC, Camporez JP, Lima-Salgado TM, Cintra DE, Akamine EH, Ribeiro LM, Almeida FN, Zanuto RP, Curi R, Boldrini SC, Liberti EA, Fiamoncini J, Hirabara SM, Deschamps FC, Carpinelli AR, Carvalho CR. Changes in food intake, metabolic parameters and insulin resistance are induced by an isoenergetic, medium-chain fatty acid diet and are associated with modifications in insulin signalling in isolated rat pancreatic islets. Br J Nutr. 2013 Jun 28;109(12):2154-65. doi: 10.1017/S0007114512004576.
- Matusheski et al. Coffee and Type 2 Diabetes Risk. In "Coffee: Emerging Health Effects and Disease Prevention" edited by Yi-Fang Chu.John Wiley & Sons, Mar 27, 2012.
- Mucalo I, Rahelić D, Jovanovski E, Bozikov V, Romić Z, Vuksan V. Effect of American ginseng (Panax quinquefolius L.) on glycemic control in type 2 diabetes. Coll Antropol. 2012 Dec;36(4):1435-40. Review.
- Muroyama K, Murosaki S, Yamamoto Y, Ishijima A, Toh Y. Effects of intake of a mixture of thiamin, arginine, caffeine, and citric acid on adiposity in healthy subjects with high percent body fat. Biosci Biotechnol Biochem. 2003 Nov;67(11):2325-3.
- Norberto S, Silva S, Meireles M, Faria A, Pintado M, Calhau C. Blueberry anthocyanins in health promotion: A metabolic overview. Journal of Functional. Foods, Available online 21 September 2013.
- Ritter RC, Ladenheim EE. Capsaicin pretreatment attenuates suppression of food intake by cholecystokinin. Am J Physiol. 1985 Apr;248(4 Pt 2):R501-4.
- Sahebkar A. Potential efficacy of ginger as a natural supplement for nonalcoholic fatty liver disease. World J Gastroenterol. 2011 Jan 14;17(2):271-2. doi: 10.3748/wjg.v17.i2.271.
- Shanmugasundaram ER, Rajeswari G, Baskaran K, Rajesh Kumar BR, Radha Shanmugasundaram K, Kizar Ahmath B. Use of Gymnema sylvestre leaf extract in the control of blood glucose in insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus. J Ethnopharmacol. 1990 Oct;30(3):281-94.
- Shiyovich A, Sztarkier I, Nesher L. Toxic hepatitis induced by Gymnema sylvestre, a natural remedy for type 2 diabetes mellitus. Am J Med Sci. 2010 Dec;340(6):514-7.
- Stull AJ, Cash KC, Johnson WD, Champagne CM, Cefalu WT. Bioactives in blueberries improve insulin sensitivity in obese, insulin-resistant men and women. J Nutr. 2010 Oct;140(10):1764-8. doi: 10.3945/jn.110.125336.
- Uribarri J, Woodruff S, Goodman S, Cai W, Chen X, Pyzik R, Yong A, Striker GE, Vlassara H. Advanced glycation end products in foods and a practical guide to their reduction in the diet. J Am Diet Assoc. 2010 Jun;110(6):911-16.e12.
- Yadav H, Lee JH, Lloyd J, Walter P, Rane SG. Beneficial Metabolic Effects of a Probiotic via Butyrate-induced GLP-1 Hormone Secretion. J Biol Chem. 2013 Aug 30;288(35):25088-97.