Insanity vs. TurboFire Interval - What's the optimal HIIT regimen?As part of her recently published master thesis, Sarah A. McGlinchy investigated the differential effects two commercial fitness programs had on the heart rate pulmonary O2 uptake, CO2 output, caloric expenditure and substrate utilization during exercise and recovery, as well as the subjective satisfaction and physical exertion of trained individuals (N=15, four males and 11 females, aged 22.3 ± 1.6 years McGlinchy. 2012).
- click here to watch a promo video on YouTube)
- Turbo Fire® Interval Training Protocol - The HIIT 30 variety of a series of DVDs that comes from the same company that sells the P90X DVDs includes a 3 min warm-up, a 3 min cool down with stretching and slow movements to get the heart rate back to normal and a series of five drills of which the first four are repeated twice and the last one three times. Drills last about 1 min and are supposed to be performed with maximum effort each is followed by one minute of active recovery (walking, jogging in place, etc.). Water breaks are allowed during the active recovery. The total length of the workout is 30 minutes and 36 seconds (click here to watch a private workout video on YouTube).
Ignore fatty acid oxidation and total calorie expenditure - pick the one you like!
The significantly less pronounced at the end of the TurboFire Intervals stand in contrast to the total the subjects were working out in the 81-90% HRmax, though. With 1000 seconds (vs. 580s) the latter was significantly longer during the Turbo Fire session. Accordingly, the subjects' respiratory exchange ratio (RER), a measure for the relation of glucose to fatty acid oxidation was significantly higher, as well.
SuppTensity Workout Perform 3 cycles of these 5 drills, each drill lasts 1 min, 45s active recovery between drills, 2 min between cyclesWhile the former was to be expected, it may appear somewhat odd at first, though, is the higher and longer-lasting post-exercise energy expenditure in the Insanity group (p < 0.05), which could yet be explained by an overall slightly more demanding (figure 1, left > exhaustion) workout, which - and this is just based on what I saw in the videos - appears to have more "complete" drills - or did you see things like push-ups in the Turbo Fire workout? Against the background that the minimal differences in intra- and post-workout energy expenditure and substrate utilization won't have any noticeable effect on the desired outcome variable, i.e. a leaner, still muscular physique, and in view of the fact that"EPOC comprises only 6-15% of the net total oxygen cost of the exercise" (LaForgia. 2006), anyway, I would fully subscribe to Sarah McGlinchy's recommendation to simply pick the workout you like - based on McGlinchy's interpration of her subjects' feedback that would be the ...
- Push ups
- Clean & press*
- Rope skipping
- Turbo Fire® for people who are "looking for more variety of movements with fun music"
- Insanity® for people for whom "music isn’t a priority", but who look for "intense motivation"
Do I suggest you buy a DVD or hop around like a jackass in the gym, let alone in front of your TV, when you prefer going to the next best park or beach doing sprints and combine those with your regular strength training program in the gym? Certainly not! Would I rather see you, your friends or family perform any of these workouts than doing exclusively strength training (let alone ultra low volume 1-rep max style) or hours of steady state aerobics if your goal is to get jacked? Abs(!)olutely ;-)
On very short notice
- Reason enough for Brandon W Too and his colleagues to conclude "that consuming a natural CHO source (raisins) [..] is well tolerated and maintains blood glucose levels and running performance similar to a commercial CHO product (sport chews)" (Too. 2012). Did you hear that Michael Phelps?
- Epi-sesamine from Lindera obtusiloba could be novel source for potent anti-obesity drug - This is at least what a recently published study that was conducted by scientists from the German Charité Universitätsklinikum in Berlin would suggest (Freise. 2012). In their in-vitro tests the active ingredient of the Japanese spice bush, which has traditionally been used for treatment of inflammation and the prevention of liver damage in Oriental Medicine, did not just prevent the accumulation of lipid droplets, it also activated the pro-apoptotic enzymes caspases-3/-7, which initiated programmed cell-death in the treated fat cells. In view of my recent blogpost on the nasty persistence of lower body fat, the latter could turn out to be of extreme importance - especially for those of you who have already lost a significant amount of body fat and are now suffering from "relative leptin deficiency" (see "Nasty Insights into the Yo-Yo-Effect" for more on how this relates to the YoYo-Effect and weight loss plateaus).
Figure 3: Mild exercise (5x 30 min / week, treadmill) boosts brain 5a- reductase and neurogenesis (Okamoto. 2012)Recently published data from the Laboratory of Exercise Biochemistry and Neuroendocrinology at the University of Tsukuba, in Japan does now add another piece to the "DHT is not bad" puzzle - one even women could come to appreciate (Okamoto. 2012): According to Masahiro Okamoto and colleagues, the exercise induced increase in 5-alpha reductase activity (5-ar converts testosterone to dihydrotestosterone) and the subsequent rise in neuronal DHT appears to be the driving force of neurogenesis (the generation of new neuronal networks / brain tissue and wiring).
- On Very Short Notice" item are the findings from Huang et al. have just published in Journal of Applied Physiology. In their paper the researchers describe the 8-weeks of moderate treadmill running had on the toxin
resistance of 6-week old rodents. Specifically, Huang et al. observed that the "exercised rats not only
performed better in the rotarod task [skilled behavior test, see video]
showed finer Purkinje cell structure (higher dendritic volume and spine
density)" (Huang. 2012).
And while this is unquestionably reminiscent
of the aforementioned neuron-building effects of DHT (which is, as you
should know increased with aerobic / volume training; cf. "Intermittent Thoughts on DHT"), the big news is that the neurons of the exercised rodents were also protected against the immunotoxin OX7-saporin.
If these results translate (I personally believe that this is not a question of yes or no, but only one of the extend to which these results translate) to any of the bazillion other toxins we are exposed to on a daily basis, this would imply that regular exercise may not just protect us from the "classic" neurodegenerative diseases such as Alzheimer's or Parkinson, but also from autoimmune diseases which have a neuronal component and often involve damage to the very Purkinje neurons the researchers found to be "bullet proof" in the study at hand.
- Children of diabetic parents benefit most from hitting the weights - "The offspring" of type II diabetics that's the somewhat surprising result of a 9-week training + 9-week detraining experiment Katherine Schofield and her colleagues from New Zealand and Denmark conducted respond particularly favorable to resistance training programs (Schofield. 2012). At the end of the initial 9 week training period, the insulin response of the children with diabetic parents was still worse than thatof their peers in the control group, but with improvements of roughly 30% they were already approaching what you may call the "normal zone", when the detraining phase begun. Contrary to the kids in the control group, whose insulin sensitivity did not change over the 9 weeks of laziness, the children of type II diabetics lost all their previously achieved improvements. Now, you could certainly argue how those poor kids are at such a disadvantage, but unless you want to feed them metformin for the rest of their lives, I suggest we should rather think of ways to teach them how to resist the bad eating habits of their parents and stick to a workout routine that will make the diabetes medication obsolete - don't you agree?
Suggested reads for everyone interested in some background info on nitrates: (1) Ask Dr. Andro: Is Creatine Nitrate Worth it? (2) Nitrates Work! First NO2 Victim in ERContrary to earlier trials in non-trained subjects, the athletes' performance did not benefit from the supplemental nitrate - despite statistically significant increases in plasma nitrate (+17%) and nitrite (+56%), by the way. Moreover, the concommitant increase in endothelin-1, a protein that constricts blood vessels, raises blood pressure and thus counters the vasodilating effects of the nitrates raises concerns regarding potential side effects that could occur once you drop the supplement. Image 5: Mineral supplements are usually not necessary, as long as you pick the right foods and drinks! What's much more likely in the Western hemisphere than deficiencies, though, are imbalances - and weekend warriors and gymbros are even more likely than your average obese pre-diabetic to run into oftentimes self-inflicted problems... there is going to be a Super Human University seminar Carl Lanore and I are currently working on - and let me tell you this, this is a topic that is literally very dear to Carl's heart.This is an impressive figure and yet, the real beauty of this study is that it emphasizes the need to re-evaluate your nutritional mineral intake, instead / before considering using dietary (let alone oily ;-) supplements!
- Bescós R, Ferrer-Roca V, Galilea PA, Roig A, Drobnic F, Sureda A, Martorell M, Cordova A, Tur JA, Pons A. Sodium Nitrate Supplementation Does Not Enhance Performance of Endurance Athletes. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2012 Jul 17.
- Freise C, Trowitzsch-Kienast W, Erben U, Seehofer D, Kim KY, Zeitz M, Ruehl M, Somasundaram R. (+)-Episesamin inhibits adipogenesis and exerts anti-inflammatory effects in 3T3-L1 (pre)adipocytes by sustained Wnt signaling, down-regulation of PPARγ and induction of iNOS. J Nutr Biochem. 2012 Jul 18.
- Huang TY, Lin LS, Cho KC, Chen SJ, Kuo YM, Yu L, Wu FS, Chuang JI, Chen HI, Jen CJ. Chronic treadmill exercise in rats delicately alters the Purkinje cell structure to improve motor performance and toxin-resistance in the cerebellum. J Appl Physiol. 2012 Jul 26.
- Kousa A, Havulinna AS, Moltchanova E, Taskinen O, Nikkarinen M, Eriksson J, Karvonen M. Calcium:magnesium ratio in local groundwater and incidence of acute myocardial infarction among males in rural Finland. Environ Health Perspect. 2006 May;114(5):730-4.
- LaForgia J, Withers RT, Gore CJ. Effects of exercise intensity and duration on the excess post-exercise oxygen consumption. J Sports Sci. 2006 Dec;24(12):1247-64.
- Muguruma K, Nishiyama A, Ono Y, Miyawaki H, Mizuhara E, Hori S, Kakizuka A, Obata K, Yanagawa Y, Hirano T, Sasai Y. Ontogeny-recapitulating generation and tissue integration of ES cell-derived Purkinje cells. Nat Neurosci. 2010 Oct;13(10):1171-80.
- McGlinchy SA. The Effect of Two High Intensity Interval Training Protocols on Heart Rate, Caloric Expenditure, and Substrate Utilization During Exercise and Recovery. University of Toledo - Submitted to the Graduate Faculty as partial fulfillment of the requirements for The Master of Science Degree in Exercise Science. 2012.
- Okamoto M, Hojo Y, Inoue K, Matsui T, Kawato S, McEwen BS, Soya H. Mild exercise increases dihydrotestosterone in hippocampus providing evidence for androgenic mediation of neurogenesis. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2012 Jul 17.
- Schofield KL, Rehrer NJ, Perry TL, Ross A, Andersen JL, Osborne H. Insulin and Fiber Type in Offspring of T2DM with Resistance Training and Detraining. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2012 Jul 17.
- Rangan C, Barceloux DG. Food additives and sensitivities. Dis Mon. 2009 May;55(5):292-311.
- Too BW, Cicai S, Hockett KR, Applegate E, Davis BA, Casazza GA. Natural versus Commercial Carbohydrate Supplementation and Endurance Running Performance. J Int Soc Sports Nutr. 2012 Jun 15;9(1):27.